Blog | Sports Rap Network

Johnson C. Smith’s Playoff Snub Defies CIAA Football Logic

Johnson C. Smith’s Playoff Snub Defies CIAA Football Logic

Image credit: Sports Rap Network

The Golden Bulls reached the CIAA title game, beat Fayetteville State during the season and still watched the Broncos receive the conference’s second postseason bid.

Johnson C. Smith’s season ended with a one-point loss in the CIAA championship game. Its postseason fate, however, became far more difficult to explain than that 15-14 defeat. The Golden Bulls, defending conference champions who had been highly ranked through the season, were left out of the Division II field while Fayetteville State received the CIAA’s second bid.

That outcome has created a legitimate fairness question for Black college football. Johnson C. Smith beat Fayetteville State during the season and played Virginia Union for the CIAA championship. Yet the Broncos, coming out of the conference’s third-place Friday Night Blitz game against Virginia State, moved ahead of the Golden Bulls when the bids were assigned.

A championship-game résumé should carry weight

The simplest argument begins with the bracket itself. Virginia Union won the CIAA championship, rallying from behind with a late 69-yard touchdown to beat Johnson C. Smith 15-14. If the conference is positioned to send two teams into the postseason, the two teams that reached the championship game would appear to have the clearest claim to those places.

That does not diminish Fayetteville State’s season or its victory in the Friday Night Blitz. The Broncos made their own case on the field. But the format produces an uncomfortable contradiction when a third-place game becomes more valuable than a championship-game appearance, particularly when the excluded finalist already owns a head-to-head victory over the team selected ahead of it. For Johnson C. Smith coach Maurice Flowers and his players, that is a brutal reward for a season that put them in position to defend their title.

The Power Index has replaced human judgment

The selection is not the result of a traditional committee debate. As Lou Williams explained, the NCAA Power Index, or NPI, now drives these decisions. In Super Region I, where the CIAA sits, four conference champions receive automatic bids, leaving only four available positions. Fayetteville State’s placement above Johnson C. Smith in that index appears to have determined the outcome.

Data-driven selection is intended to create consistency, but consistency is not the same as credibility. An index can measure schedule inputs and results according to its formula, yet it can also struggle to reflect the practical meaning of a conference tournament structure. When a system overlooks a championship-game participant in favor of a team it defeated, fans are right to ask whether the model is answering the wrong question.

The issue is bigger than one disappointed program. Division II postseason access can shape a school’s visibility, recruiting momentum and the memory of an entire senior class. That makes transparency essential. If the NPI is going to overrule what looks obvious in the standings and on the field, the schools and supporters affected deserve a clear explanation of why.

The SIAC offers a clearer path to a deep run

While the CIAA controversy leaves Johnson C. Smith at home, the SIAC enters the postseason with a compelling pair of contenders. Benedict and Kentucky State occupy the top two spots in Super Region II after meeting in a dramatic conference championship game. Benedict erased a 24-point deficit, pushed the game to overtime and defeated Kentucky State to secure the title.

Benedict’s body of work makes it an especially intriguing threat. The program opened the season by beating Johnson C. Smith 32-10, finished 10-1 and has returned close to the level it reached under former coach Chennis Berry. Coach Ron Dickerson Jr. has restored Benedict as the SIAC’s standard-bearer, though Kentucky State has shown it has the personnel to challenge that status.

Williams sees a realistic chance that Benedict and Kentucky State could meet again in the regional final, with the winner advancing toward the national semifinals. That possibility underscores the contrast with the CIAA situation: the SIAC’s best teams have an opportunity to settle their status in the postseason, while Johnson C. Smith is denied the chance to respond after falling short by one point in its conference title game.

What It Means

The Golden Bulls cannot change the NPI result, but the disappointment should not be brushed aside as routine postseason math. College football has always valued winning games that matter most. A process that places less value on a championship-game berth than a third-place result risks losing the confidence of the people who invest in the competition.

Johnson C. Smith’s omission should prompt the CIAA and NCAA to examine how postseason criteria are communicated and whether the formula properly reflects conference championship results and head-to-head outcomes. The Golden Bulls earned more than sympathy. They earned an explanation—and Black college football deserves a selection process that passes the common-sense test as well as the statistical one.

Substantive update: